top of page

In-house Counsel, an Outsourced Legal Department, or Both?

2 hours ago
6 min read

Many growing businesses eventually face the same question: should we hire an in-house lawyer? The discussion often starts with the amount already being spent on external legal services. Couldn't we hire our own lawyer for the same money?

It's a fair question, but comparing costs alone won't provide the answer. What matters more is the type of legal issues a company faces, how regularly they arise and how broad a range of expertise is needed. Just as important is understanding who currently takes care of legal matters. Without an in-house lawyer, responsibility is often shared between management, HR and external advisers. Individual matters may be handled well, but coordinating the bigger picture can easily receive less attention.

In practice, the options include ad hoc legal advice, an in-house lawyer, an outsourced legal department or a combination of these. Having worked both in-house and as an external legal adviser, I've seen both sides. Ultimately, the right approach depends on how legal work actually arises within the business.


When is ad hoc legal advice enough?

Not every company needs an in-house lawyer or even ongoing legal support. If legal questions only arise occasionally, project-based legal advice may be sufficient for individual contracts, transactions or other specific projects. This allows the company to access the expertise it needs without committing to an ongoing arrangement.

There's nothing wrong with this approach, provided it works in practice. Someone within the company needs to recognise when legal advice is required, provide the lawyer with sufficient background information and ensure that agreed actions are followed through.

If no one takes responsibility for the bigger picture, legal matters can easily pile up alongside other responsibilities. Similar issues may be handled differently across the organisation, and no one may notice when individual questions begin to develop into a broader problem.


When is an in-house lawyer the right choice?


An in-house lawyer can be a good solution when legal matters arise continuously and the lawyer needs to be closely involved in the company's day-to-day operations. This might involve contracts, employment matters, regulatory requirements or a rapidly changing business environment. If there is enough work and legal expertise needs to be consistently involved in business decisions, hiring an in-house lawyer can make excellent sense.

The greatest advantage of an in-house lawyer is continuity. They understand the business and know what level of risk the company is willing to accept. Rather than being brought in only when a specific legal question has already arisen, they can contribute while the business is still exploring its options. In practice, this might mean supporting HR in difficult employee situations, developing contract templates or assessing the legal implications of a new service during its planning stage.

During my years working in-house, I learned that businesses rarely want the longest possible legal analysis. They want to know what they can do, what they should do and what risks a decision involves. A good in-house lawyer can answer these questions because they also understand the business implications of those decisions.


One lawyer can't cover everything


Hiring an in-house lawyer doesn't usually eliminate the need for external legal support. One lawyer may be an excellent generalist, but they don't need to be a specialist in every area of law. In fact, recognising the limits of one's own expertise is an important part of being a good lawyer.

The same applies to capacity. Day-to-day legal work may be perfectly manageable for one lawyer, but an acquisition, a major contract project, restructuring consultations or a significant regulatory initiative can multiply the workload almost overnight. Even when the expertise is there, there may simply not be enough hours in the day. That's why in-house lawyers often need external specialists alongside them.


When does an outsourced legal department work best?


Not every company has enough legal work to justify a full-time in-house lawyer. The need may be regular but uneven: several hours of legal support one week and hardly any the next. The nature of the work can also vary considerably. A single month might bring an employment contract, a commercial agreement, a data protection question and a corporate governance matter.

An outsourced legal department is particularly well suited to situations like these. The company has a dedicated lawyer who knows the business and effectively works as an in-house lawyer, supported by a broader legal team. No single lawyer needs to know everything, and the company doesn't have to hire a separate specialist for every area of law.

In practice, this might mean a lawyer working with the company one or two days a week, attending regular meetings and handling day-to-day legal matters. When needed, specialists in employment law, data protection, technology contracts or corporate law can step in. The level of support can also be adjusted when the company takes on a larger project.


What does an outsourced legal department look like in practice?


This is exactly how we work with our client Siirto Brand. Folks Counsel Katri spends one day a week as part of the Siirto Brand team, effectively acting as the company's in-house lawyer. She knows the people, the ongoing projects and the types of legal questions that typically arise in the business. There's no need to spend time explaining the entire background every time a new matter comes up.

This also makes a difference to when and why people reach out to their lawyer. It's easier to call someone familiar before a question has even been clearly defined and ask whether an issue is worth looking into more closely. The lawyer can get involved early in the planning process, while recurring negotiations can help shape better contract templates and practices. The relationship goes beyond reviewing completed agreements or solving problems that have already arisen.

Another benefit of understanding the business is being able to put legal advice into the right commercial context. A contract clause that is perfectly acceptable for one company may represent a significant risk for another. Not every risk needs to be eliminated, and not every question requires the same level of detailed analysis. What matters is understanding what the business is trying to achieve and which risks it is prepared to take.

Folks' approach also gives clients access to the expertise of our entire team. A complex employment law issue, data protection matter or corporate arrangement can be handled by the lawyer with the most relevant specialist knowledge. Clients don't have to choose between continuity and specialist expertise. Above all, what sets this model apart from occasional legal advice is having someone who understands the business and takes responsibility for keeping agreed legal matters moving forward.

When does combining an in-house lawyer with an outsourced legal department work best? For many companies, the best solution is an in-house lawyer supported by an external legal team. The in-house lawyer might handle day-to-day contracts, corporate governance and advice to management, while more complex employment matters, acquisitions or major technology projects are handled together with external specialists. This allows the company to retain a dedicated person responsible for its legal matters without having to build all the necessary expertise and capacity internally.

It's also worth planning for absences and changes in personnel. An interim lawyer can step in during an in-house lawyer's parental leave, another extended absence or a recruitment process, taking responsibility for agreed tasks for a fixed period. If the external legal partner already knows the business, the handover is usually much smoother. That's why it's often worth establishing a working relationship before the need becomes urgent.

What about the costs?

The discussion about hiring an in-house lawyer often comes down to which is cheaper: employing someone or buying legal services externally. But simply comparing a monthly salary with an hourly rate can be misleading. In addition to salary, the cost of an in-house lawyer includes employer contributions, recruitment, training and equipment. On the other hand, a full-time lawyer can be a highly cost-effective solution when there is enough work and the need is continuous.

An external lawyer's hourly rate is generally higher, but the amount of support can be adjusted to match the company's needs. The business can also draw on the expertise of several lawyers without having to employ a specialist in every field. When comparing costs, it's worth considering how much time management and other employees spend dealing with and coordinating legal matters themselves.

I wouldn't make the decision based on hourly rates or annual costs alone. If the need for legal support is predictable and continuous, an in-house lawyer may be the most efficient solution. If the need fluctuates or covers several specialist areas, an outsourced or hybrid model may work better. The key is having the right expertise available at the right time. What really matters is how legal support works in practice

Whatever approach a company chooses, it's essential to agree on who is responsible for coordinating legal matters and ensuring they move forward. Simply having a lawyer available to call doesn't mean someone is overseeing the bigger picture. This is easily overlooked when legal support is assessed only in terms of individual assignments and costs.

At Folks, we understand this perspective from first-hand experience. Many of our lawyers have worked in in-house legal teams and know what businesses expect from their legal advisers. That's why we aim to provide legal advice that helps clients make decisions, rather than simply identifying every possible legal issue.

Ultimately, what matters isn't whether a lawyer's email address ends with the company's domain or that of a law firm. It's whether they understand the business, are sufficiently involved in its day-to-day operations and can provide the right expertise when it's needed.

Explore Folks' outsourced legal department services or tell us more about your company's situation. Together, we can find the legal support that best meets your business needs.



Hymyilevä nainen mustissa laseissa ja valkoisessa paidassa seisoo kiviseinää vasten kädet ristissä. Folksin osakas Anna Paimela

 

Anna Paimela

Partner

+358 40 1648626







bottom of page